I hate when a company touts the very points someone would be looking for a product to excel in, only to find the product actually produces the exact opposite results.This product was not smudge-proof, water-proof, or creamy as touted.I doubt that it's even 100% cruelty-free and Vegan as it claims to be but how would you know anyway?I ended up throwing it out after the first use just so I don't accidentally use it again.I cannot explain the positive reviews on this product unless most of them are older and the company had changed the formula more recently.
Afraid to us them because of breaking. Color is good.Can they be returned. Without packaging?
This eyeliner goes on smoothly! No tugging. Stays put all day!! Beautiful color (coffee). Does not irritate my sensitive skin or eyes. Will be buying more. Would be great if they expanded to other colors ..like greens, purples, blues, bronzes.